Why Coaching Is a Profession, Not Just a Marketing Label

Coaching Is a Profession: The Difference Between Marketing Coaching and Being Able to Coach

There has been a conversation circulating online recently about a high-profile event and the way speaking opportunities were sold.

I’m not going to get into the details of that particular story because I don’t know everything that happened, and this episode isn’t about putting an individual on trial.

But it did get me thinking about something I care about deeply:
What do we actually mean when we call someone a coach?

Online, that word is used to describe a remarkable range of people.

Someone might be teaching business strategy.

Someone else might be sharing their personal story.

Another person might be selling access to a stage, a network or a retreat experience.

They may be excellent at what they do.

But none of those things, on their own, tell us whether somebody can actually coach.

And I think that distinction matters now more than ever.

Coaching is a profession.

There are skills to learn, standards to work towards, ethical responsibilities to uphold and boundaries to understand.

When we lose sight of that, it becomes very difficult for clients to understand what they are buying, and for people entering the profession to understand what good coaching practice actually looks like.

We need more examples of that.

So today, I want to talk about the difference between building a visible coaching business and becoming a capable coach.

Marketing matters, but marketing is not coaching

Let me start by saying that marketing is essential in business.

Coaches need to be able to explain their work, reach the people they can help, and, of course, earn a living.
We are running businesses, after all.

I teach coaches about building their businesses, and I know how challenging that part can be.

But marketing and coaching ask very different things of us.

Marketing helps somebody decide whether they want to work with you.

Coaching is what happens after they do.

Once somebody steps into a one-to-one coaching session, joins your group programme or arrives at your retreat, the quality of your social media content becomes much less relevant.

What matters then is how you work with the person in front of you.

Can you listen beyond their first description of the problem or goal?

Can you notice an assumption without telling them what to think?

Can you help them find their own insight while remaining alert to what may sit outside your scope?

Perhaps the conversation is moving into therapeutic territory.

Perhaps what the client actually needs is consulting.

Can you recognise that?

Can you respond appropriately when the conversation goes somewhere you did not expect?

Can you work at the level your client actually needs?

That takes skill.

And it takes practice.

It is entirely possible to be a highly skilled coach whose marketing has not yet caught up with the quality of their work.

You can be a very well-kept secret.

And equally, audience size tells us very little about somebody’s ability to hold a skilled coaching conversation.

Not every form of helping is coaching

Part of the confusion comes from using “coaching” as an umbrella term for almost every form of help.

But there are important distinctions.

If you draw on your own experience and say:
“Here is what worked for me.”

you may actually be mentoring.

Mentoring can be enormously valuable.

But it is not the same thing as coaching.

If you assess somebody’s situation and recommend a solution, you may be consulting.

Again, that may be exactly what the person needs.

Perhaps they want somebody to tell them the steps they need to take to solve a problem or achieve an outcome.

That is useful.

But it is different from coaching.

Training has its place too.

Sometimes somebody needs to learn a particular method, acquire knowledge or practise a skill in order to achieve their goal.

And therapy, of course, is a distinct profession with its own training and scope.

There are times when a client needs support that coaching is simply not equipped to provide.

Coaching may sit alongside any of these approaches.

A practitioner may offer more than one.

The important thing is that they have the relevant competence and that they make it clear which role they are taking at any given moment.

The problem comes when those roles blur, and the client does not know.

The responsibility becomes even greater in groups

This distinction becomes especially important in group environments.

If you host an event and invite 10, 20 or 50 people into a room and describe it as a coaching experience, you are taking responsibility for much more than the agenda, the atmosphere or the music.

You need to consider:
How will people participate?
What have they consented to share?
What happens if something sensitive arises?
How will you manage confidentiality?
What sits inside your scope?

And is the experience you have promised actually one you are equipped to deliver?

The same applies to a retreat or an off-site.

A beautiful venue can bring people together.

A compelling invitation can fill the room.

Neither can, by itself, create a well-held coaching experience.

Coach education needs to create capability

This is one of the reasons I care so much about coach education and equipping coaches with the skills they need to create real, lasting transformation.

A good coach training programme should give you far more than a collection of questions and a certificate at the end.

You need opportunities to coach.

You need to be coached.

You need feedback.

You need opportunities to examine the habits you may not notice on your own.

And you need to develop judgement, including the judgement to recognise when another form of support would serve the client more effectively.

That is part of being a professional.

Why credentialing matters

Credentialing gives us a way to work towards shared standards and demonstrate that professional development.

That matters to me.

At the same time, I would never suggest that a set of letters automatically makes somebody a wonderful coach.
The credential matters because of what should sit behind it:

• education
• coaching experience
• mentor coaching
• observed practice
• evaluation
• ethical development
• ongoing learning

And because the coach continues developing after receiving it.

If you have heard me speak about ACC and PCC before, you will know that I see them as stages of professional development rather than badges to collect or letters to put after your name on LinkedIn.

ACC “Associate Certified Coach” provides a strong foundation in coaching competencies and ethical practice.
As coaches develop towards PCC, the work asks for increasing responsiveness and depth.

You are listening to the person, not just the topic.

You are noticing patterns, beliefs and values.

You are becoming more comfortable working with complexity.

And you are learning to remain in partnership without rushing in to provide the answer.

That does not happen simply because your coaching hours accumulate.

Experience matters.

But what you learn from that experience matters too.

Who are you becoming as a coach?

That leads to the question I would like coaches to ask themselves, wherever they are in their development:
Who am I becoming when I am in the room with my clients?

Am I becoming more curious?
Am I more able to listen?
Am I more aware of the effect of my own assumptions?
Can I recognise not only what I can offer, but also the limits of what I can offer?

These questions may be less exciting than talking about how quickly you can fill a programme.

But they are central to the promise we make when we invite somebody to work with us.

What should clients ask when choosing a coach?

And if you are looking for a coach yourself, I would encourage you to ask questions too.

Ask about their training.

Ask about their experience.

Ask what happens in their coaching sessions.

Ask how they work.

Ask whether you will receive coaching, mentoring, consulting or some combination of those things.

And if they do offer a combination, ask how they make those distinctions clear.

You are entitled to understand what you are paying for when you hire a coach.

Professional development at the Mindset Coach Academy

This is why, at the Mindset Coach Academy, we offer coach education from foundational ICF ACC development through to PCC-level development and continuing coach education.

We include live practice, mentoring and feedback because coaching capability develops through doing the work and then reflecting on it.

You need time to pause.

To notice how you are coaching.

To see the habits you have developed.

To notice where you are growing.

And to understand how your coaching is evolving.

We also support coaches to build viable businesses.

Of course we do.

Being able to find clients matters.

Being able to communicate your work matters.

Being able to generate revenue matters.

But the work those clients experience once they arrive matters just as much.

And I think that is a distinction our profession needs to keep talking about.

When another online coaching controversy appears…

The next time there is a big online conversation involving somebody described as a coach, it may be worth pausing before deciding what that particular story says about coaching as a whole.

Ask:
What service was actually being offered?
What was promised?
Was the person practising coaching?
Or were they providing mentoring, consulting, training, networking, speaking opportunities or something else under the broader coaching label?

We can think critically about individual stories without lowering our expectations of the profession.

In fact, that is precisely why I wanted to have this conversation.

Coaching can be incredibly powerful work.

People trust us with their goals.

Their uncertainty.

Their hopes.

Their decisions.

That deserves to be taken seriously.

And taking coaching seriously begins with learning how to coach, and continuing to learn how to coach well, in a way that creates meaningful, sustainable transformation.

If you are interested in developing your own coaching capability, take a look at the ICF-accredited programmes, advanced coach development and continuing education opportunities available through the Mindset Coach Academy:
https://mindsetcoachacademy.com/

Join our Community!

You can also follow us on our social media channels:

• • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn